
In New York City, time is one of the most expensive line items in any development budget. Every month spent waiting on approvals is a month of carrying costs, interest, and uncertainty that someone has to pay for.
That’s why a recent announcement caught the attention of the development community. Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Department of City Planning Director Sideya Sherman have named the 12 community districts where the voter-approved Affordable Housing Fast Track will begin on January 1, 2027. In those districts, eligible rezonings that create affordable housing will go through a 90-day public review, roughly four months faster than the traditional Uniform Land Use Review Procedure.
The districts were not chosen at random. Together they make up one-fifth of the city's 59 community districts, yet they produced just 724 of the 63,870 affordable homes created between 2021 and 2026, about 1% of the total.
For this installment of Crexi's Conversation with the Chairman, we sat down with Bob to talk about what the Fast Track changes, what it doesn't, what it means for land values and owners in those 12 districts, and whether speeding up the process is enough to get more housing built.
Knakal: In plain terms, it is a shorter road to a rezoning.
Today, if a developer needs a zoning change to build housing, they go through ULURP: the Community Board, Borough President, City Planning Commission, and City Council. That takes roughly seven months once the clock starts, and often much longer before it starts.
In November 2025, voters approved changes to the City Charter that create an alternative. Starting January 1, 2027, eligible rezonings that create affordable housing in these 12 districts will go through a 90-day review. The Community Board and Borough President still weigh in, and the City Planning Commission makes the decision. That takes about four months out of the process.
Why should people care? Because in development, time is not neutral. Time is money, and time is risk. Anything that makes the process faster and more predictable changes what a developer can afford to pay for land, and whether a project gets built at all.
Knakal: It tells you that the burden of building affordable housing has not been shared evenly across the city.
About 1% of the production came from 20% of the districts. As someone who loves statistics, I find that a striking number. If you were managing a baseball team and 20% of your lineup produced 1% of your hits, you would want to understand why.
There are a lot of reasons a district can end up in that position. Some have zoning that simply doesn't allow much density. Some have had strong local opposition to new development. Some have high land values that make affordable projects hard to pencil. Most likely, it is a combination.
What the Fast Track does is address one piece of that equation: the approval process. It says that in the places where the least affordable housing has been built, the path to a rezoning should be shorter. That is a reasonable place to start. But we should be clear that process is only one of the reasons those numbers are so low.
Knakal: It changes the math in two ways: duration and uncertainty.
Duration is the obvious one. A developer who needs a rezoning is often carrying the land, paying interest on an acquisition loan, paying architects, attorneys, and consultants, and paying real estate taxes, all while generating little or no income. Four fewer months of that is real money.
But uncertainty is the bigger one. When a developer underwrites a site that requires a rezoning, they are not just pricing in the time. They are pricing in the risk that the approval doesn't happen, or that it comes with conditions that make the project less valuable. The longer and less predictable the process, the bigger the discount they apply to the land.
Remember how residual land value works. Start with what the finished building is worth, subtract the cost to build it and the profit the developer needs, and the land gets what is left. When you reduce the risk and the carrying cost, more is left over. In theory, that should show up in what developers are willing to pay for sites in these districts. The more they can pay for land, the more compelling their offers become to sellers. More compelling offers mean more sellers may be willing to sell. If sites trade, units can get built.
It is not a dramatic change on its own. But at the margin, four months and more certainty can be the difference between a project that pencils and one that doesn't.
Knakal: I think it is, and I actually think keeping those steps is important.
People sometimes hear "fast track" and assume it means cutting the community out. It doesn't. The neighborhood still gets its say. Environmental review still happens. Landmarks are still protected. What changes is the length of the road and the number of stops along the way.
That matters because one of the biggest problems with the traditional process has never been that the community gets a voice. It is that a project can survive every other step and still be stopped or reshaped at the end. A shorter, more defined process reduces that risk.
The caution I would offer is that the 90-day review is not the whole timeline. Before a project ever enters public review, it has to go through pre-certification with City Planning, and that has historically taken a long time—in some cases, years! The city's Block by Block plan says it wants to cut pre-certification from about two years to six months. If that happens alongside the Fast Track, the combined effect could be very significant. If it doesn't, the 90 days at the end will help, but the bottleneck will simply move to the front. Cutting the pre-certification phase is where a tangible difference can be made. If the city is serious about creating more housing, this is a must.
Knakal: Yes. Any owner in one of these districts should at least ask the question.
The Fast Track only applies to rezonings that create affordable housing, so the relevant owner is someone whose property could support more housing than the current zoning allows. That might be a low-rise commercial building, a parking lot, a warehouse, a one-story taxpayer on a wide street, or a site near transit.
If a developer can now get a rezoning in 90 days instead of seven months, with more certainty, that site may be more attractive to a buyer than it was a year ago. That doesn't mean every owner in these districts just got richer. It means some owners may be sitting on more potential value than they realize.
The first thing I would tell an owner is to understand what could be built on the site under a rezoning, not just under current zoning. The second is to understand the affordability requirements that would come with it, because they directly affect what a developer can pay. The third is to understand timing. These rules take effect January 1, 2027. Owners who understand their position early are in a much better spot than those who figure it out after the market has.
Knakal: The common thread is speed. Almost every piece of it is about shortening the distance between an idea and a building.
The Block by Block plan targets 200,000 new affordable homes and the preservation of 200,000 more over the next decade, with more than $22 billion committed over five years. The SPEED Task Force is aiming to cut development timelines by eight months across affordable projects and by up to two years for projects that need a zoning change. Then there are the charter proposals on the November ballot. One speeds up sales of small city-owned parcels, and another creates a single permitting hub so builders don't have to go agency by agency.
I think the direction is right. New York has a 1.4% rental vacancy rate, the lowest in 50 years. We have a supply problem, and you can't solve a supply problem without building. There will be an announcement soon about the number of affordable units created this year and it will be embarrassing for the administration. Therefore, I think we will see changes to 485-x, as that legislation is completely misguided and is the reason larger scale rental buildings are not being built. But that is another conversation for another day.
At the same time, I think it is important to look at the whole picture. The same administration that is speeding up approvals is also increasing enforcement on owners and adding costs in other places, while also increasing enforcement on owners and adding costs in other areas. Developers are going to look at the total equation. Faster approvals help. But if costs rise faster than the process speeds up, the net effect is smaller than the headline suggests.
Knakal: I see three main risks.
The first is economics. A faster rezoning doesn't help if the project doesn't pencil. Construction costs are high, interest rates are still well above where they were for most of the last decade, and affordability requirements limit revenue. In districts where market rents are lower, those affordable units are subsidized by fewer market-rate units, and that can be hard to make work.
The second is capacity. A 90-day clock only works if City Planning and the other agencies have the staff to meet it. Timelines are commitments, but they depend on people. If the agencies are underfunded, the gains can disappear quickly.
The third is opposition. Some of these districts have the lowest production precisely because there has been strong resistance to new development. A shorter process doesn't make that resistance go away. It may simply concentrate it into fewer, more intense moments, and in some cases it could lead to legal challenges.
None of these risks mean the Fast Track is a bad idea. They mean it is a tool, not a solution. The test will be simple: how many affordable homes actually get built in these 12 districts over the next five years compared to the 724 created over the last five years. That is the statistic I will be watching.
Knakal: This is exactly where a platform like Crexi can be most valuable.
If a district has produced very little affordable housing, that often means it is not on the radar of the developers who build it. The affordable housing development community is specialized. These are firms that understand tax credits, HPD financing, regulatory agreements, and income requirements. Historically, many of them have focused on the neighborhoods where they have built before.
The Fast Track creates a reason for them to look somewhere new. But they can only buy what they can find.
A platform like Crexi puts a site in front of a much broader universe of buyers, including affordable housing developers, mission-driven buyers, and investors from outside the city who may have a specific interest in this kind of opportunity. It also puts information like zoning, location, and comparable sales in front of those buyers quickly, which helps them decide whether a site is worth pursuing.
When the rules change, the first people to understand the new opportunity usually have the advantage. The job for brokers and platforms like Crexi is to make sure the right buyers see these opportunities early, and that owners in these 12 districts understand the value the new rules may have created.
BKREA is an investment sales firm that exclusively represents sellers of investment properties and development sites in New York City.
To contact Bob Knakal:
Crexi is a powerful platform for prospecting, evaluating opportunities, connecting with clients, and closing commercial real estate transactions.
To contact Ashley Kobovitch: