My Commencement Address: The ‘Why’ Often Comes Later

‍

Read the Full Article on Commercial Observer - Click Here

‍

Bob Knakal shares a powerful message in his commencement-style reflection: extraordinary success is rarely built on motivation alone. After more than four decades in commercial real estate, Knakal argues that the highest performers are driven not by constant inspiration, but by discipline, movement, and an internal force they often do not fully understand when their journey begins.

The essay challenges the modern belief that people must first discover their “why” before taking action. Instead, Knakal explains that purpose is often revealed through action itself — through persistence, failure, growth, and experience accumulated over time.

Key Lessons from “The ‘Why’ Often Comes Later”

• Discipline Matters More Than Motivation
  Motivation is emotional and temporary, while discipline creates consistent action regardless of mood, circumstances, or external validation.
• Purpose Is Often Discovered Through Action
  Many successful people begin moving long before they fully understand what is driving them. Clarity frequently emerges after years of experience and reflection.
• Elite Performers Operate on Standards, Not Feelings
  High achievers develop routines and habits that allow them to perform consistently instead of waiting to “feel motivated” before taking action.
• Self-Discovery Comes from Engagement with Life
  According to Knakal, people often discover who they are by actively participating in life, facing challenges, competing, learning, and adapting.
• Waiting for Perfect Clarity Creates Stagnation
  One of the biggest mistakes people make is standing still until they feel certain about their future. Progress often requires moving through uncertainty.
• The Rearview Mirror Explains the Journey
  Looking backward often reveals the deeper emotional drivers behind ambition, including insecurity, adversity, validation, freedom, or the pursuit of meaning.

A Different Perspective on Success

Knakal reflects on entering commercial real estate in 1984 without a fully defined mission or life plan. Rather than waiting for perfect clarity, he focused on movement, discipline, and building momentum.

Over time, he came to believe that success rarely follows a perfectly organized sequence of:

1. Discover purpose
2. Feel motivated
3. Take action
4. Achieve success

Instead, the process is often reversed:

1. Internal drive creates movement
2. Action builds discipline and expertise
3. Experience creates self-awareness
4. Purpose becomes clearer over time

Why This Message Resonates Today

In an era where many people feel pressure to immediately “find their passion” or fully map out their future, Knakal’s perspective offers a more practical and liberating framework. The essay emphasizes that uncertainty is normal, and that meaningful careers and lives are often built step by step rather than through instant clarity.

The central message is simple: movement creates momentum, and momentum often reveals purpose.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main message of Bob Knakal’s commencement address?

The speech argues that success is built more on discipline and consistent action than on motivation or immediate clarity of purpose.

What does “The ‘Why’ Often Comes Later” mean?

It means many people only fully understand their deeper purpose and motivations after years of experience, growth, and reflection.

Why does Knakal emphasize discipline over motivation?

Because motivation fluctuates emotionally, while discipline creates consistent behavior and long-term progress regardless of feelings.

How does Knakal believe people discover purpose?

He believes purpose is often revealed through action, engagement with life, failure, learning, and repeated experiences.

What advice does the essay give young professionals?

Do not wait for perfect clarity before starting. Take action, remain disciplined, and allow experience to shape understanding over time.

Why is this message relevant today?

Many people delay action while searching for certainty or purpose. The essay encourages movement and growth even in the absence of complete clarity.

‍