Read the Full Article on Traded - Click Here
BKREA arranged the $31 million sale of 38 West 21st Street, a 12-story office building in Manhattan’s Flatiron District. The transaction highlights a notable shift in Manhattan’s office investment market, where renewed demand for traditional office properties is increasingly competing with office-to-residential conversion strategies.
Located between Fifth Avenue and Avenue of the Americas, the 1908-built property contains approximately 68,808 square feet and is situated within the Ladies’ Mile Historic District. BKREA marketed the property as a potential office-to-residential conversion opportunity, attracting interest from both residential conversion buyers and traditional office investors.
The property sold for $31 million, or approximately $450 per square foot, demonstrating continued investor interest in well-located Manhattan office properties.
The marketing process revealed a meaningful shift in buyer sentiment. While residential conversion investors initially dominated the process, five office investors ultimately competed for the property during the final weeks of marketing.
The property was initially positioned as a potential conversion opportunity, but the transaction demonstrated that traditional office investment is once again becoming a compelling strategy for buyers.
By presenting the property to multiple buyer groups, BKREA created competition between office investors and residential conversion buyers, helping maximize value for the seller.
The property is located in the historic Ladies’ Mile District, one of Manhattan’s most established commercial neighborhoods, with strong transportation access and proximity to major Midtown South employment centers.
Sioni Group acquired the property with plans to renovate and modernize it for continued office use, signaling confidence in the long-term outlook for Manhattan office assets.
According to Knakal, positive absorption and office-to-residential conversions have helped reduce Manhattan office vacancy from approximately 20% to about 12%, bringing the market closer to equilibrium.
The transaction provides an important snapshot of the changing Manhattan office market. For several months, prospective buyers primarily evaluated the property through the lens of residential conversion. As marketing progressed, however, office investors entered the process and competed aggressively for the asset.
According to Bob Knakal:
“The lesson from it is that the meaty part of the bell curve in terms of office-to-residential conversion is in the rearview mirror at this point.”
The transaction demonstrates how shifting market fundamentals can create new opportunities for sellers. By marketing an asset around multiple potential investment strategies, BKREA was able to attract a broader buyer pool and capitalize on changing investor sentiment.
The property sold for $31 million, or approximately $450 per square foot.
The property is located between Fifth Avenue and Avenue of the Americas in Manhattan’s Flatiron District, within the Ladies’ Mile Historic District.
It is a 12-story office building containing approximately 68,808 square feet.
Yes. BKREA marketed the property as a potential office-to-residential conversion opportunity, but strong demand from office investors ultimately drove the transaction.
Sioni Group acquired the building and plans to renovate it for continued office use.
BKREA’s Bob Knakal, Faraz Cheema, and Ryan Candel represented Jack Vogel Associates in the transaction.
The sale suggests that investor confidence in Manhattan office properties is improving as leasing activity strengthens, vacancy declines, and buyers increasingly return to traditional office investment strategies.
Get tailored industry and listing news, Map Room, and Bob Knakal's insights in your inbox!
Follow us on
